|
Scott Wilkinson Thomas Norton Fred Manteghian Kim Wilson HT Geeks The Movie Room Ultimate Demos Recently Added
Video Displays
Speakers
Sources
Electronics
Accessories Features Audio/Video News CES 2010 CEDIA 2009 CES 2009 CEDIA 2008 CES 2008 CEDIA 2007 HE 2007 CES 2007 CEDIA 2006 HE 2006 CES 2006 Thomas J. Norton Michael Fremer Joel Brinkley Scott Wilkinson AV Links Contact Us Flatscreen TVs LCD TVs Plasma TVs HDTV AV Receivers Home Theater in a Box Digital Projectors DLP Projectors Video Projectors Surround Sound Dolby 5.1 |
The Tannoy Highline Arena 500 5.1-Channel Speaker System:
In terms of the "thing" itself, the NHT Classic system provides far more for the money and better value in terms of sheer mass, driver power, electronic flexibility and the ability to move huge amounts of air and produce prodigious bass. But that doesn't necessarily translate into better overall sonic performance, as I quickly found out!
The Sound of Five Tiny Dual Concentric Drivers This was before knowing the cost and thinking it was a far less expensive system, mind you, but even after learning the relatively hefty price tag (thanks no doubt to the weak $ relative to the £—about 2:1), this system remained impressive, particularly in terms of its freedom from mid-band congestion and its sweet, yet airy top end and open, spacious presentation. To these ears, the Arena 500 system epitomized transparency and subjective neutrality. The presentation was free of glaze, grain, glare, harshness, metallic shinola, and all else that can be objectionable between the midrange and top end. Yet it was airy, open, graceful and crystalline-fast, backed by black backdrops and fast settling time. How many times have I heard A3's "Woke Up This Morning" opening to The Sopranos? A hundred or more? Probably. And through every system reviewed over the past six years. Yet despite its small size, the Tannoy system's presented the song's percussion with greater clarity and transparency, and it resolved inner detail better than I can recall from any system that's been here. The cleanliness and speed of transients were most obvious as was a sense of overall musical organization. No doubt the "point source" approach contributed to the sensation of focus, clarity and overall organization. Also impressive was the seamless, almost effortless satellite/subwoofer integration. It was surprisingly easy to achieve, without a "hole" developing between the two. Deep bass was there when called for, and the subwoofer never gave away its location, nor did it produce thumpy or "one note" bass. It was good down to around 30Hz in my room, which was good for everything but the deepest gut shaking sound effects and the lowest organ stops.
Equally satisfying was the center speaker's performance. It's the most difficult to get right in my experience. Most centers I've heard suffer from a discontinuity caused by a stuffy bottom or a spotlit top. The Arena 500 produced voices that had shape, weight and that rare center channel commodity, believability—as if the actor was standing in the room just behind the speaker. There was weight without chestiness, and articulation and clarity without edge or etch. The coaxial driver's dispersion pattern made the presentation equally effective off-axis as on horizontally, and its tilting cradle-stand also kept vertical dispersion from being an issue. Having five small, impressively capable point sources produced an acoustic bubble the equal of any heard in my room and better than most, with the location of all five main speakers never intruding upon the sonic picture. Pans in all directions happened with seamless, non-mechanical precision.
But more remarkable was the system's microdynamic performance, probably a result of both small, fast drivers, and well-braced enclosures. It was possible to hear way into the soundstage and retrieve the lowest level small shifts in dynamic information that distinguishes cardboard cutouts from seemingly living entities.
The Downside However, the Arena 500 system never sounded wimpy or dynamically challenged—at least when used in a typical large living room environment, placed around ten feet from the listener, and driven with sufficient power. In fact, the system sounded far larger than its modest size would suggest. A rated efficiency of 88dB is about average these days. But if you're considering this system, don't hold back on the power. The recommended power is a puny 25-100W. Go for more. One additional caveat: the towers are tall and not particularly stable, so consider that if you have small children or large, rambunctious dogs, particularly if you need to place the speakers in heavily trafficked areas.
Conclusion Add an attractive, beautifully finished package that's compact and complimentary to a variety of settings and you have an easy to recommend system that will provide musical and cinematic satisfaction without physically imposing upon a room. It's too bad the feeble dollar pushes the price up so high, but even as priced this is a system many discerning listeners will be happy to have. Overall, Tannoy's Arena 500 system is among the handful of the most satisfying 5.1-channel systems that I've reviewed.
Highs
Lows
Article Continues: Review System »
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

Surprisingly, the supplied system, with a pair of satellites in the rear on integrated stands retails for $5,438, or $28 more ($18 more not including the $10 mystery system discount). That's because while the satellites cost $180 less per speaker, the stands cost $189 each. In other words, if you want this Tannoy system and can accommodate rear towers, go for them!
Tannoy made its reputation designing and building studio monitors for music production and from everything written so far you might think the system's musical reproduction was equally satisfying, especially timbrally. And it was—at all SPLs. This was a system that didn't sound shut down when played at low, late night levels. When it needed to, it also managed to play louder than I ever would have imagined based upon its baffle size. And that's the reaction I had before finding out the miniscule size of the actual driver hidden behind the non-removable grilles.